They look at download numbers. Follower counts. CPM rates.

None of those alone will tell you if the campaign is going to work.

The questions that matter but are not always considered are the ones most brands never think to ask.

This came up on a recent episode of The Content Business and it's worth turning into a proper framework.

Here are two of the most overlooked due diligence checks we use at Pod Partnerships before recommending a creator to any brand.

Has a competitor already been there?

This one cuts both ways.

If a competitor has sponsored this creator before and isn't still doing it, that's a signal worth paying attention to.

Brands that see results renew. Simple.

If someone in your space ran a campaign and quietly disappeared after one episode, the odds are it didn't land.

That creator's audience probably isn't the right fit for your category. Or the conversion just wasn't there.

Either way, you now have free data telling you not to repeat the mistake.

The opposite is also worth using.

Before you even approach a creator, ask whether any of your direct competitors are actively sponsoring them right now.

If yes, walk away.

You don't want your brand sitting in the same slot as the company you're trying to take customers from. The audience has already heard the pitch. You're not competing on podcast real estate, you're competing in the listener's head, and you're arriving second.

Find a creator where your category is untouched. That's a virgin audience for your product, and that's where you actually have a chance to own the association.

Do they actually have opinions?

This one is underestimated massively.

Before working with any creator, spend time consuming their content. Not skimming it. Actually watching and listening.

Ask yourself: does this person have genuine, consistent opinions? Do they take a position and hold it?

Creators who sit on the fence don't build diehard audiences.

They build casual ones.

And casual audiences don't buy things on a recommendation.

The creators with the most commercially valuable audiences are usually the ones who say something that divides people. They've got listeners who strongly agree with them. Those listeners trust them. And when they recommend something, those listeners act.

We had this situation with a brand looking to promote a savings account. The creator had a perfect audience on paper, right demographics, right size, right niche. But his entire brand was built around the idea that traditional saving is a waste of time.

It would've been a disaster.

Not just underperforming. Actively damaging, for the creator and the brand.

The audience would've seen straight through it.

The best creators work with brands that make sense for who they are. That selectivity is actually a green flag. It means their audience trusts them because they've protected that trust consistently.

Creators who will say anything for an ad slot have audiences who know it.

Those audiences don't convert.

What this means practically

Before you sign any creator partnership, do these two things:

The brands that skip this step tend to be the same ones that write off creator marketing as "not working."

It worked. They just picked the wrong creator.

If you want help with creator selection and due diligence before committing a budget, drop me a message.

Listen to “The Content Business” on YouTube or your favourite podcast app or follow us on social media